Shortlists vs Vincere comparison
It started as an upgrade from Bullhorn. Then the add-ons started.
Vincere was the modern alternative. Better interface, better UX. But since the Access Group acquisition, it's been slowly turning into everything it was supposed to replace.
“Something happens and then I have to go and do it in the CRM. Every. Single. Time.”
At a glance
Shortlists vs Vincere — quick overview
The honest take
Here's what's actually happened to Vincere.
Vincere was genuinely good — a better alternative to Bullhorn, cleaner interface, more modern. Plenty of recruiters made the switch and were happy.
Then Access Group acquired them. And since then: features that used to be standard — like contact enrichment — have moved behind add-on paywalls. The roadmap has slowed. And the 90-day notice requirement — which was always there — now feels a lot more like a trap than a formality.
Vincere has moved to an unbundled model where the core CRM and the AI packs are priced separately, so your real monthly cost creeps up every time you add another pack. Shortlists keeps AI, enrichment and natural-language database search in one flat $120/user/month — no packs to track.
Why agencies switch
What drives recruiters away from Vincere.
Add-on creep
Features that were once included are being moved to paid add-ons. Every quarter, the effective cost goes up.
“Expensive data exports, basic features moved to add-ons.”
The 90-day trap
Want to leave? You need to give 90 days' notice. Miss the window and you're locked in for another year.
“Vincere ends around July — 90-day notice required.”
Still reactive, not proactive
Vincere records what happened. You still have to go in and log everything manually after every call, email, and meeting.
“I want something to happen in the CRM that knows it's already happened.”
Price went the wrong way
Post-acquisition, pricing has only moved in one direction. The value proposition has weakened as costs have grown.
“Currently pays for expensive Vincere subscription.”
Feature by feature
Everything side by side.
Pricing accurate as of Q1 2026. Verify current Vincere pricing with their sales team.
Pricing
One price. No add-ons.
Vincere
Core CRM and add-on packs for enrichment, portals, and advanced AI are priced separately.
One flat $120/user price, month to month — before you even count Vincere's add-on packs.
Switching is easier than you think
Your 90-day notice period can work in your favour.
Vincere has historically required a written notice period, commonly reported at around 90 days, before you can leave. With Vincere's pricing model shifting, it is worth confirming your exact terms directly rather than assuming the old figure still applies. Either way, the practical move is the same: give notice, then start on Shortlists straight away, so the free, CTO-led migration finishes and your team is live before your Vincere term ends.
Some Vincere users report paying extra just to get their own data out when they leave. Your Shortlists migration is free either way, and your data stays exportable going forward, so the same thing never happens to you again. We've done it from Vincere exports before — it takes one night, and your pipelines come across intact.
And everything that used to be an add-on — the client portal and AI notetaker — is already included the day you go live.
Book your free migration call →What recruiters say
Rated 4.8/5 on G2, trusted by 55+ recruitment agencies.
“Shortlists cuts the time it takes to build a shortlist and keeps everything tidy and consistent. I can share a clean, professional output with clients.”
Faraj Jaboor
Consultant · via G2
“Shortlists has completely transformed how we present candidates. It saves hours of work, looks professional, and makes our clients' experience seamless.”
Aaron Hayhurst
Founder, Web3 Insights: Talent · via G2
“Streamlined my entire client presentation process. And my clients love it.”
Robin Beattie
Founder, Akaina Talent · via G2
Questions
Shortlists vs Vincere — common questions.
Ready to make the switch?
Join 55+agencies who've already moved. Your data comes with you — free, overnight, handled personally.
$120/month · No contracts · Cancel anytime